Obama Administration Reveals GOP Leaders’ Betrayal on Common Core in Ed Bill

December 21, 2015

by Emmett McGroarty


Secretary of Education Arne Duncan (photo credit: Center for American Progress via Flickr, CC BY-ND 2.0)

Secretary of Education Arne Duncan (photo credit: Center for American Progress via Flickr, CC BY-ND 2.0)

Anti-Common Core activists tried for months to warn Congress that the new federal education bill (the Every Student Succeeds Act, or ESSA) was a disaster that would cement, not overturn, the odious progressive-education philosophies of the Obama Administration. Except for 64 House members (click here to see how your member voted) and 12 senators (click here to see how your senators voted) who were brave enough to buck Republican leadership, their warnings were dismissed. Now comes confirmation that the activists were dead on — and that Republican leadership, including Sen. Lamar Alexander, Rep. John Kline, and House Speaker Paul Ryan, carried out a cynical scheme to betray their constituents and give the Administration everything it wanted.

This confirmation comes from someone who should know — Education Secretary Arne Duncan.

In a just-released interview with Politico Pro, Duncan expressed joyful incredulity at how wonderful ESSA turned out to be from the Administration’s point of view (meaning, how bad it is for children, families, and the Constitution). “I’m stunned,” he said, “at how much better it ended up than either [House or Senate] bill going into conference. I had a Democratic congressman say to me that it’s a miracle — he’s literally never seen anything like it.”

What’s so good about ESSA, according to Duncan? “[I]f you look at the substance of what is there . . . embedded in the law are the values that we’ve promoted and proposed forever. The core of our agenda from Day One, that’s all in there – early childhood, high standards [i.e., Common Core], not turning a blind eye when things are bad. For the first time in our nation’s history, that’s the letter of the law.”

So just as the grassroots warned, the “core of the [leftist] agenda” is embodied in the unread 1,061 pages of ESSA. Every member of Congress who claims to be conservative and who voted for this, deciding to trust the establishment rather than the knowledgeable constituents who know this issue intimately, should hang his or her head in shame.

And as for the establishment — assuming Duncan is telling the truth, and as a lame duck on his way out the door, why shouldn’t he? — what they did is beneath contempt. In Duncan’s own words, speaking of Alexander and Kline:

We had many, many conversations behind the scenes . . . . And I said for us to support it, they’d have to shed their far, far right [i.e., constituents who support the Constitution and oppose Common Core] . . . . I honestly didn’t know if they’d have the political courage to do that. But they both said they would and they did. I give them tremendous credit for that.

And here he recounts his interaction with Ryan:

About a month before [final Senate passage of the bill], I ran into Speaker [Paul] Ryan and we just talked briefly. I asked if he was going to back this, whether he’s willing to take on the far right. I just asked him straight up. And he said, “Absolutely. We’re going to back this.” And, he did. That’s when I thought it had a real shot.

Here is where Duncan describes the tactics of the Republican betrayal:

We were intentionally quiet on the bill – they asked us specifically not to praise it – and to let it get through. And so we went into radio silence and then talked about it after the fact. . . . Our goal was to get this bill passed – intentionally silent on the many, many good aspects of the bill . . . [W]e were very strategically quiet on good stuff . . . .

So Alexander, Kline, and Ryan asked the Administration to keep quiet while they slipped its policies into the bill that they would then market to their “far right” as something that overturned those policies. The “far right” wasn’t fooled, but many, many members of Congress were.

And then Duncan took a victory lap:

The final thing is we have every ability to implement, to regulate the law . . . it’s just a Washington typical storyline. . . .  And candidly, our lawyers are much smarter than many of the folks who were working on this bill. There are some face-saving things you give up, some talking points you give up, which we always do because we’re focused on substance.  And we have every ability to implement.  That’s all I’ve ever wanted.

Ever the savvy bureaucrat, Duncan realizes that implementation is often more important than statutory language — and he’s been given language that he can run with, all the way to progressive Utopia.

Duncan brags that his people outsmarted the Republicans working on the bill, which is certainly easy to believe. But maybe it was more than stupidity on their part — maybe the card-carrying members of the education establishment such as Lamar Alexander really agree with the leftists and have really bought into their dangerous philosophies.

But either way, these revelations should end the pathetic charade that Congress just restored states’ autonomy in education. Members of Congress can stop sending out mendacious press statements bragging about how they wrenched back power from Obama and Duncan. The only acceptable statements from them should be along the lines of, “I’m sorry, and I choose not to run for re-election.”

And as for Alexander, Kline, and Ryan — they have simply betrayed their constituents, especially the last few who actually believed any integrity remained in the Republican establishment. Remind us again why we need a Republican Party. Has it not gone the way of the Whigs?

Emmett McGroarty is the executive director of APP Education.


Emmett McGroarty is the director of APP Education.

Archive: Emmett McGroarty

9 comments on “Obama Administration Reveals GOP Leaders’ Betrayal on Common Core in Ed Bill”

  • KarenBracken says:

    marshwill ARE YOU KIDDING ME.  We don’t have to change the Constitution to cancel unconstitutional legislation we already have that provision in the current Constitution and our weak kneed local government refuses to stand up for our rights.  So how is the fraud you are proposing change that.  If they don’t do what our constitution already gives us the right to do what in God’s name makes you think they will follow the new rules?  The problem is who we are electing and the American people not the Constitution.  You people are delusional and DANGEROUS.  It is obvious those of you that want to change the current Constitution are being deceived and truly do not understand the Constitution we already have because if you did you would know we have every protection we need already in the current Constitution.  And we wonder why we are in trouble.  It is people like you that are the problem.

  • marshwill says:

    One of the likely amendments to be proposed at the Convention of States Project would provide a means for the States to review and cancel such bad legislation (and similarly bad Supreme Court decisions.  If you are tired of the “Imperial” Federal government and its over-reach into our daily lives–along with the “progressive” loss of liberty over the past several decades, sign the petition in support of the Convention of States Project.  Get the facts and sign at:  bit.ly/FSjoCh

  • KarenBracken says:

    I hope you don’t think any of us are surprised at his candor.  He is basking in rubbing salt into our wounds.  But he has declared war and he will not be prepared for what is coming next.  Do not mess with a momma bear.  My question is what will the states do to tell the US Department of Education (which is an unlawful, unconstitutional agency) to take their ESSA and shove it where the sun don’t shine.  The states need to keep ALL their money in the state and only send the feds what they need to support the 18 enumerated powers given to them by WE THE PEOPLE.

  • Rita Cetti says:

    TimSlekar Rita Cetti Enjoy the delusion as long as you can.  We fought a world war to avoid this once before.  Now it’s called “Progressivism”.  This time it might work because the people we’d have to fight is ourselves and our delusions that it can’t happen again.

     http://constitution.com/u-n-agenda-2030-massive-global-migration-of-refugees/

  • TimSlekar says:

    This delusion—where champions of progressivism and champions of conservatism are engaged in a battle for the soul of American public schools—purposely blinds citizens to the neo-liberal and neo-conservative dismantling of traditional public education.
    http://bustedpencils.com/2015/12/a-right-wing-delusion-essa-is-leftist-and-progressive-victory/

  • TimSlekar says:

    Rita Cetti TimSlekar This delusion—where champions of progressivism and champions of conservatism are engaged in a battle for the soul of American public schools—purposely blinds citizens to the neo-liberal and neo-conservative dismantling of traditional public education.
    http://bustedpencils.com/2015/12/a-right-wing-delusion-essa-is-leftist-and-progressive-victory/

  • crunchymama says:

    Now let’s have a talk about how Duncan himself betrayed American families and children and teachers….

  • Rita Cetti says:

    TimSlekar You’re right, except for one thing. This is an election year and everyone is stacked up to move Hillary into the White House to further fund the Clinton Global Initiative into the forever.  Tell me if you really believe it would be beyond Duncan to lie about all this?  I’m not saying it’s not true that the Republicans betrayed their constituents, I’m saying the deck is so heavily stacked by the worldwide big money in every aspect of our lives already that the government has everything to do with the fact that you can’t tell the sheep from the wolves anymore, and that’s the way they made it and that’s the way they want it to be. Progressives have been given a green light, and they’ve taken the blue and red one too!

  • TimSlekar says:

    One big problem with this post.  Obama and Duncan are not progressives ushering in a new wave of “leftist” reforms.  Stop imagining that education policy is easily divided into progressive and conservative positions.  Education policy in the US has been “corporatist, neo-liberal and neo conservative” for the last thirty years.  There is nothing progressive about test and punish and mandatory and standardized curriculum (common core).  This is BIG GOVERNMENT—repubs and dems—maintaining control of a valuable market and entrenching a surveillance system.  The betrayal is not repubs that went along with a “leftist” education agenda.  The betrayal is that the overwhelming support in the house and senate had nothing to do with education philosophy and everything to do with maintaining control.  Our ruling class is celebrating the victory as “we” remain stuck in a left right delusion.

Comments are closed.