❓WHAT HAPPENED: A shocking 96 percent of pleas for assistance to help homeless New Yorkers during a recent cold snap went unanswered.
👤WHO WAS INVOLVED: City Council members, outgoing Department of Social Services Commissioner Molly Wasow Park, Emergency Management Commissioner Zach Iscol, and Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration.
📍WHEN & WHERE: The events unfolded following a January 24 winter storm in New York City, with hearings held Tuesday to address the crisis.
💬KEY QUOTE: “These deaths are not inevitable. They are the result of gaps and outreach, shelter capacity, mental health services and follow-up.” – Julie Menin, City Council Speaker
🎯IMPACT: At least 15 of 18 deaths during the deep freeze were directly linked to hypothermia, raising concerns over the city’s response to the homeless crisis.
New York City officials are facing mounting scrutiny after a deadly winter cold snap exposed major failures in the city’s response to homeless residents in crisis. Data from the city’s 311 system showed that 96 percent of calls requesting homeless assistance during the freeze went unresolved. The city’s medical examiner later confirmed that 15 of the 18 deaths recorded during the cold spell were caused by hypothermia.
At a City Council hearing, outgoing Department of Social Services Commissioner Molly Wasow Park and Emergency Management Commissioner Zach Iscol said the extreme weather made it difficult to locate people living outdoors. Council leaders rejected that explanation. Council Speaker Julie Menin said the deaths were avoidable. “These deaths are not inevitable. They are the result of gaps and outreach, shelter capacity, mental health services, and follow-up,” she said.
Council member Phil Wong highlighted delays in handling emergency calls, noting that overnight reports of homeless individuals in distress were initially routed through the non-emergency 311 system rather than 911. He said the lag in upgrading the response during the freeze likely cost lives.
After January 31, the city shifted overnight homeless assistance calls to 911 under an enhanced “Code Blue” alert, which is triggered when temperatures fall below freezing. Critics said the move came too late and argued that Code Blue alerts alone are ineffective without rapid, proactive outreach. Medical professionals echoed those concerns.
The crisis has unfolded amid broader criticism of Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration. Following the major winter storm, critics accused the city of failing to promptly clear garbage and slush from streets, while the mayor’s Gracie Mansion residence was kept “pristine.”
The immigrant mayor has also drawn controversy for appointing Cea Weaver as executive director of the Mayor’s Office to Protect Tenants, despite the fact she has previously said she wants to “impoverish the white middle class.”
Join Pulse+ to comment below, and receive exclusive e-mail analyses.
