Joe Biden‘s continued reshaping of the U.S. judiciary comes with an especially egregious nomination in his 50th batch of judicial nominees, bringing his total appointments to 244 judges. The 81-year-old Democrat incumbent announced he intends to elevate Maine Superior Court justice and former U.S. attorney Julia Lipez to the First First Circuit Court of Appeals. Her father, Kermit Lipez, currently serves as the senior judge on the same federal circuit.
Critics of Justice Lipez contend she routinely makes soft-on-crime rulings, especially concerning violent drug and sexual offenses. In the 2021 death of 14-month-old Karson Malloy, Lipez sentenced the child’s mother to only four years in prison, with the additional six years of the sentence being suspended.
Karson Malloy was found dead in the Oakland, Maine, apartment of his mother, Ashley Malloy. His pajamas were covered in fentanyl, and the bedroom in which he was discovered was littered with drug paraphernalia. Despite Lipez determining that Ashley Malloy knew about and aided a fentanyl drug trafficking operation, the Maine justice granted the woman a questionably light sentence. Karson Malloy’s grandmother had asked for the death penalty for her daughter over role her in her grandson’s death.
Additionally, Lipez allowed a pedophile accused of sexually abusing two girls, aged four and nine at the time, to go free on bail before trial. Upon his conviction, Lipez suspended half of his sentence—arguing the pedophile “has a lot of good in him.”
In a statement announcing her nomination, the Biden White House stressed the need for diversity on the court, adding that Lipez is “extraordinarily qualified, experienced, and devoted to the rule of law and our Constitution.”