Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira, employees and co-defendants of Donald Trump in Jack Smith‘s documents prosecution, are slated to appear in court to contest the charges they face.
Both Nauta, who started as Trump’s valet and later ascended to a personal aide position, and De Oliveira, who also started as a valet and rose to Mar-a-Lago property manager, are pivotal in Smith’s larger narrative against the former President. The special prosecutor alleges they helped their employer try to conceal boxes containing classified information from the authorities — charges they deny.
Nauta’s lawyers are seeking to persuade Judge Aileen Cannon to throw out charges against him centered on allegations he moved 64 boxes from a Mar-a-Lago storage room to Trump’s living quarters before a lawyer was due to examine them for classified material requested in a federal subpoena.
Nauta’s lawyer, Stanley Woodward Jr., argues Smith’s indictment does not even allege Nauta “knew that there were classified documents on premises” at Mar-a-Lago and that he could not have committed a crime simply by moving boxes with contents of which he was unaware.
“How could providing documents for President Trump to review prior to subpoena compliance be an act that obstructs justice?” Woodward’s filings ask.
Lawyers for De Oliveira, accused of helping Nauta move around 30 of the boxes, also argue he did not know what was in them or that they were wanted for a federal investigation. They also note the boxes were “reviewed only hours after they were moved” for subpoena compliance in any case.
The pair also deny asking Mar-a-Lago technician Yuscil Taveras to delete security footage of the boxes being moved. Even if such a request was made, Taveras did not comply with it, and the footage was preserved.