A senior economic advisor to Kamala Harris‘s 2024 presidential campaign has confirmed the Democratic nominee intends to impose a tax on unrealized capital gains. Bharat Ramamurti, who serves as an economic aide to Kamala Harris, dismissed criticism of the Democratic Party‘s presidential candidate’s tax plan during an appearance on CNBC on Wednesday.
“I think that this reaction to unrealized gains is a little funny given that I bet that the majority of people watching right now are already paying a tax on unrealized gains,” Ramamurti contended during the interview. He added: “It’s called a property tax.”
CNBC host Joe Kernen abruptly cut Ramamurti off, describing the Harris advisor’s “property tax” canard as “tiring” and “always the go-to answer.” Indeed, Kernen is correct that a property tax—defined as a use tax—is dissimilar from a tax on unrealized capital gains.
A PROPERTY TAX?
Property taxes pay for local services such as public schools, police, and firefighters. However, a tax on unrealized capital gains would tax the unsold value of a capital good—such as stock shares in a company. The shareholder would be taxed on the assumed value of the shares without them being sold—meaning if they’re later sold for a loss, the taxpayer has been legally overtaxed by the government.
When pressed on how Harris‘s proposal to tax unrealized capital gains would act in any way like a use tax, Ramamurti unconvincingly sputtered: “All the revenue that comes in from these unrealized gains taxes and the other taxes in the tax—in the Harris plan—are going to go to creating what she calls ‘more opportunity.'”
Despite Ramamurti’s unconvincing spin, the reality is a tax on unrealized capital gains could prove economically disastrous. While Harris claims only the highest income earners would be impacted, it is these same high earners who have the largest market impacts as investors. An unrealized capital gains tax would likely dissuade these individuals from future market actions.
WATCH:
CNBC HOST MOCKS KAMALA’S UNREALIZED CAPITAL GAINS TAX PLAN
Kamala’s economic advisor, Bharat Rama, appeared on CNBC to argue in favor of the VP’s tax plan for unrealized capital gains.
Host Joe Kernen made fun of Rama’s explanation of how property tax is unrealized gains tax.… pic.twitter.com/q5XbMOj8pU
— Mario Nawfal (@MarioNawfal) August 28, 2024