A new lawsuit aimed at President Donald J. Trump’s administration has landed on the desk of Judge James Boasberg, who previously blocked the America First leader’s efforts to deport Venezuelan gangsters to El Salvador using the Alien Enemies Act. The case, filed Wednesday by American Oversight, accuses Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and other top officials of breaking federal records laws by discussing Houthi attack strategies in a Signal group chat.
Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA) has urged the Barack Obama-appointed Boasberg to step aside, as his past rulings reveal a clear bias against Trump’s team. “It’s no coincidence Boasberg got this case,” Issa said, doubting the judge would recuse himself but arguing it would be the right move for the court’s credibility.
President Trump has called for Boasberg’s impeachment, and Rep. Brandon Gill (R-TX) has filed articles to initiate this process.
American Oversight claims the administration flouted the Federal Records Act, which mandates preserving official government communications, in its Houthis discussion. The group points out that agencies typically require officials to save messages from apps like Signal by forwarding them to official systems—something they allege didn’t happen here. The suit targets Hegseth, Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Director John Ratcliffe, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, alongside the National Archives.
White House officials deny the Signal chat was used for “war planning,” as some media have suggested. Testifying before the House Intelligence Committee on Wednesday, Gabbard stressed that no classified information was shared. Gabbard said the national security advisor has owned up to the slip, and the National Security Council is investigating.
While American Oversight purports to be nonpartisan, Influence Watch notes it “frequently appears explicitly partisan in its choice of investigative projects,” with conservatives arguing it was founded in 2017 with the express purpose of waging a lawfare campaign against the first Trump administration.
Several key leadership figures, including founder Austin Evers—a former senior counsel in the Obama administration—are tied to Democrats and Democratic super PACs.