The leftist Guardian newspaper claims the obvious targeting of WNBA star rookie Caitlin Clark is “in good faith.” In a feature for the newspaper, far-left writer Manny Fidel tries to spin the controversy over some of the overly aggressive actions other players took toward Clark as a right-wing conspiracy theory.
“Gone are the days where such controversies were born out of actual controversy,” Fidel writes before adding: “Clark lives in a country whose conservative party has simply moved on from good faith and open-mindedness.” While some fouls in basketball can certainly be unintentional, the fact that game officials have ruled several of those committed against Clark as being flagrant signals the hits were intentional, meant to either disrupt her play or potentially cause her injury. The most recent incident occurred this past Sunday, where Chicago Sky rookie Angel Reese appeared to club Clark in the head with her arm intentionally.
The rivalry between Clark and Reese began in college when Clark and the Iowa Hawkeyes were defeated by Reese and the Louisiana State (LSU) Tigers in the 2023 NCAA women’s basketball championship. Despite the defeat, Clark went number one overall in the 2024 WNBA draft, while Reese was taken several picks later at number seven overall.
A FOUL IS A FOUL.
For the Guardian, public outrage over Clark’s apparent targeting is a non-controversy that Fidel contends is driven by racism. The Guardian writer points to the allegedly tense NCAA championship game with the “optics of [Clark’s] mostly white Iowa team facing off against Reese’s mostly Black LSU team.” The line appears to excuse flagrant targeting if it is committed in the cause of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI).
Great sports rivalries can involve physical and even arguably ‘dirty’ play—the rivalry between Larry Bird and Magic Johnson saw its fair share of physicality. However, excusing what is glaringly an instance of targeting because partisan opponents have pointed out the problem does nothing for the safety of the players or the betterment of the rivalry.