Chris Philp, the Tory shadow home secretary who vowed on Friday to shut the planned asylum site at MoD Bicester (Piddington) “straight away,” spent 2020 and 2021 as immigration minister defending almost exactly the same style of military base usage for asylum seekers. At the time, he lauded them as “safe, secure, habitable, fit for purpose.”
Philp made his recent pledge in Piddington village hall after a clash with Reform UK’s Zia Yusuf, who had demanded an apology for the Tory border record. Philp, instead of responding on the substance, told Yusuf to “read the room,” then posted: “We will shut down the planned migrant camp at Piddington. With Kemi Badenoch as PM and me as Home Secretary the camp will close and illegal immigrants be deported.” The National Pulse has previously reported the row.
But Philp’s own, recent record tells a wildly different story than the one he was spinning in Piddington.
In an October 2020 written answer, Philp confirmed the Home Office was working “with the Ministry of Defence to identify and to utilise MOD sites at short notice,” as “contingency accommodation.” Napier Barracks in Kent and Penally Training Camp in Pembrokeshire opened that September. In January 2021, he wrote that the two sites “were immediately available to be used to house asylum seekers and are safe, secure, habitable, fit for purpose and correctly equipped in line with existing contractual requirements for asylum accommodation.”
That month, a Covid outbreak swept Napier. Some 200 residents and staff caught the virus. On 3 June 2021, the High Court ruled that the Home Office’s view that Napier was adequate for the claimants’ health was irrational. A week later, Philp told MPs: “I categorically reject the allegation that the Home Office, the Government and the UK are not doing their reasonable bit to support asylum seekers.” The £1 billion a year spent on asylum support for 60,000 people, even he admitted, was “a staggering sum.”
Both camps opened under a Tory government, with Philp answering for them. Small boat arrivals rose from 8,466 in 2020 to 28,526 in 2021. Even in opposition, after the Epping hotel ruling in August 2025, he wrote: “The last govt used other accommodation, which could be used here pending deportation.”
In other words, Philp was closer to being the progenitor of the Piddington-style scheme than he is a believable challenger to such measures.
The Bicester scheme is for up to 1,256 migrant men, not the “1,500” Philp has claimed. Residents would be free to come and go. Housing Secretary Angela Rayner granted planning permission on Thursday. The National Pulse has previously reported earlier Home Office papers that put the figure at 3,510 places for a village of about 350, and the parish’s symbolic secession vote.
A Home Office spokesman said planning permission “allows us to continue to progress the use of MoD Bicester. However, a final decision to proceed is yet to be taken.”

