The National Pulse.
Donate
NEWS · 1m ago

NIH Chief Bhattacharya Calls for Probe Into Fauci and Allies Suppressing Lab Leak Theory Anonymously.

NIH director Jay Bhattacharya has asked Nature Medicine to open a formal, independent investigation into whether Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, and Jeremy Farrar made uncredited contributions to the 2020 paper that dismissed a laboratory origin for Covid.

NIH Chief Bhattacharya Calls for Probe Into Fauci and Allies Suppressing Lab Leak Theory Anonymously.

On Wednesday, Jay Bhattacharya, director of the National Institutes of Health, asked Nature Medicine to open a formal, independent investigation into whether Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, and Jeremy Farrar made uncredited contributions to a March 2020 paper used to dismiss a laboratory origin for Covid, and to consider whether that paper should be corrected or retracted.

Bhattacharya asked the editors to provide, within 30 days, a planned scope of their review and a timetable. In the letter, he wrote that a March 6 email transmitting a later draft “thanked Fauci, Collins, and Farrar for their ‘advice and leadership’ and invited further comments before publication.”

“Although its acknowledgements identify support from the NIH and Wellcome Trust, they do not name Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, or Jeremy Farrar as authors or contributors.”

The paper, “The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2,” was published on March 17, 2020 by Kristian G. Andersen, Andrew Rambaut, W. Ian Lipkin, Edward C. Holmes, and Robert F. Garry. It stated: “Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus.” Fauci, then director of NIAID, cited the paper at a White House briefing the following month. Collins was then director of the NIH, and Farrar of the Wellcome Trust.

Nature Medicine has declined to comment.

Advice and Leadership.

The National Pulse has previously reported that on January 31, 2020, Andersen emailed Fauci that “unusual features” of the virus “(potentially) look engineered.” The next day Farrar organized a conference call at which Fauci, Collins, and a group of virologists discussed the virus’s origins. House Republicans later said this was when Fauci and Collins were first warned the virus may have leaked from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, as The National Pulse has also previously reported.

By February 4, Farrar had estimated the chance of a lab leak at 50:50. Holmes gave a 60:40 estimate in favor of an accidental release. A draft was sent to Fauci and Collins three days later, on February 4. Farrar suggested laboratory manipulation be described as “improbable” rather than “unlikely.” The published paper contains no reference to biosecurity problems in Wuhan.

Months later, Collins emailed Fauci, concerned that the paper had not sufficiently squashed the lab-leak hypothesis, and asked whether NIH could do more to “put down” the theory. The next day Fauci cited the paper from the White House podium.

In Slack messages released earlier this year by Senator Rand Paul, Andersen wrote on July 11, 2020, that the paper “was pretty strong in saying ‘there’s no way’, but I have less confidence in that statement at this stage,” and that work it described as being performed “all of the world” had “exclusively been going on at WIV.”

Andrew Rambaut, in a February 2020 Slack message, wrote: “Given the shit show that would happen if anyone serious accused the Chinese of even accidental release, my feeling is we should say that given there is no evidence of a specifically engineered virus, we cannot possibly distinguish between natural evolution and escape so we are content with ascribing it to natural processes.”

A July 2023 House select subcommittee majority report accused Collins and Fauci of exerting undue influence on the paper in order to “kill the lab leak theory” and “avoid blaming China.” The letter cites the characterization of Fauci as having prompted the preparation of the paper, of Collins as encouraging publication, and states that Farrar organized the call, circulated drafts, and helped facilitate publication. Collins had earlier emailed Fauci that “three fringe epidemiologists” needed “a quick and devastating published take down.”

Bhattacharya co-authored the Great Barrington Declaration opposing lockdowns, and was named NIH director by President Donald J. Trump, a nomination The National Pulse has previously reported. 

Bhattacharya has asked the journal that published the paper to examine whether Fauci, Collins, and Farrar should have been named on it, and whether the dismissal of a laboratory origin should still stand.

Enjoy an ad-free experience

Comments0