The National Pulse.
Donate
NEWS · just now

Dem-Appointed Judge Blocks Law Defining ‘Male’ and ‘Female’ by Biological Sex.

Democrat-appointed Judge Leslie Halligan sided with plaintiffs who identify as transgender, intersex, and "Two Spirit."

Dem-Appointed Judge Blocks Law Defining 'Male' and 'Female' by Biological Sex.

A state judge in Montana has blocked officials from enforcing a law establishing biological definitions for male and female, siding with progressive legal activists suing on behalf of transgender-identifying residents.

Missoula County District Court Judge Leslie Halligan, appointed by Democrat former Governor Steve Bullock, issued a preliminary injunction halting Senate Bill 437 while legal challenges proceed. Legal activists with Helena-based Upper Seven Law brought the challenge on April 6, representing plaintiffs who identify as transgender, intersex, and “Two Spirit.” In her ruling, Halligan claimed the injunction was required to eliminate confusion surrounding earlier court blocks against a comparable 2023 statute and “avert inconsistent enforcement of a statute that plaintiffs have shown is likely unconstitutional.”

Biological Reality vs. Gender Ideology.

Senate Bill 437 updated multiple sections of Montana’s legal code to establish clear definitions for “male,” “female,” “sex,” and “gender.” Crucially, the measure stipulates that “gender” must be treated as identical to biological sex rather than encompassing subjective gender ideology concepts.

The statute serves as a follow-up to Senate Bill 458 from 2023, which judges previously struck down twice, initially in June 2024 over title-clarity rules, and later in February 2025 under the state constitution’s equal protection provisions. Republican Governor Greg Gianforte enacted SB 437 this past March, holding the measure for nearly 12 months after its passage to keep it separate from the legal battles surrounding SB 458.

Republicans Defend ‘Commonsense’ Statute.

Following the April lawsuit, Gianforte and House Speaker Brandon Ler defended the legislation as a straightforward recognition of human biology.

“This law codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex, male and female, while protecting people born intersex and not infringing on transgender individuals’ ability to identify with whatever gender, but not sex, they wish,” Gianforte and Ler said in their spring statement. “To no one’s surprise, activists have moved to add this law into ongoing litigation to stop it from going into effect. … The State of Montana will defend this duly enacted law and ensure it gets a fair hearing in Montana’s judiciary.”

Upper Seven Law litigation director Molly Danahy celebrated Tuesday’s block via a written statement, accusing lawmakers of attempting to sidestep the courts. “After the court found the state’s first attempt to erase transgender, non-binary, intersex, and Two Spirit Montanans unconstitutional, the Legislature made a second attempt to pass essentially the same law — and then took unprecedented steps to avoid judicial review,” Danahy said, adding that “even these extraordinary procedural shenanigans — including holding the bill for nearly a year before signing it into law — couldn’t save it from ordinary constitutional review.”

Privacy and Equal Protection Claims.

After state attorneys filed their response on May 22 and arguments were heard in Missoula on June 19, Halligan rejected the state’s contention that differences in statutory wording set SB 437 apart from the blocked 2023 law. While acknowledging the text is not identical, Halligan argued the practical impact mirrors the earlier statute by enforcing a “state-mandated binary classification of sex that, under this court’s prior ruling, infringes on Montanans’ right to define their own gender identity.”

“The court has found that plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that SB 437 violates the rights to privacy and equal protection and that enforcement will cause ongoing irreparable harm,” Halligan claimed.

Image by Katrin Bolotsova.

Enjoy an ad-free experience

Comments0