Americans voiced their opposition to Arlington National Cemetery’s (ANC) decision to remove the Confederate Memorial during a public comment session on Wednesday. The Army is seeking public input as part of the legal process to determine the memorial’s historical significance and how best to dismantle it, following a congressionally-mandated study that found the structure ‘problematic’.
Many participants, including veterans with both Union and Confederate heritage, argued for preserving the memorial, citing its artistic value and symbolic representation of reconciliation. Some expressed concern that removing the memorial would lead to division rather than unity. However, some still supported its removal – asserting that there should be no memorials honoring those who fought against the United States.
The Naming Commission, established by Congress in 2021, is tasked with identifying and removing names, bases, and other Department of Defense assets that honor the Confederate States of America or individuals who voluntarily served for the Confederacy. The Pentagon’s final report recommended removing the bronze upper part of the memorial while leaving the granite base intact to avoid disturbing graves. However, commenters contended that the memorial commemorated the movement towards reunification after the Union’s victory, rather than glorifying the Confederacy. Critics also argue that dismantling the memorial would destroy a monument symbolizing peace, harmony, and reconciliation. ANC will host a virtual public scoping meeting on August 23rd to gather further comments on the removal and relocation of the Confederate Memorial’s statue and bronze elements.
Opposition to the removal of the Confederate Memorial centers on its historical and sentimental value, as well as the fact that it serves as a grave marker for some buried at Arlington. Moses Ezekiel, a Jewish-American Confederate veteran and Virginia Military Institute cadet, is buried at the base of the memorial, according to ANC’s website. Some opponents of the memorial’s removal have accused the decision of being antisemitic based on Ezekiel’s Jewish roots.