A conservative watchdog group, the American Accountability Foundation (AAF), has revealed that four medical malpractice cases have been filed against Dr. Monica Bertagnolli, President Biden’s nominee for the National Institutes of Health (NIH) director. AAF researchers argue that these cases raise concerns about Bertagnolli’s medical abilities, supervisory skills, and temperament. One case from 1999 in New York resulted in a finding of liability against Bertagnolli for a botched hernia surgery, with damages amounting to nearly $500,000. Another ongoing lawsuit in Massachusetts involves the wrongful death of a 34-year-old mother. Bertagnolli has not yet commented on the allegations.
If confirmed by the Senate, Bertagnolli would be just the second woman to lead the NIH and has been praised by the White House for her expertise as a surgical oncologist, cancer researcher, educator, and physician-leader. However, the AAF has identified these medical malpractice lawsuits as important factors that should be examined before her Senate confirmation hearings take place. The cases involve allegations of incompetence, negligence, and deviations from standard medical practice. The AAF argues that these lawsuits raise questions about Bertagnolli’s fitness to lead the NIH.
In addition to the 1999 New York case and the ongoing Massachusetts lawsuit, two other lawsuits have been filed against Bertagnolli related to medical malpractice. In one case, Bertagnolli was accused of failing to diagnose the plaintiff’s colon cancer. The other case involved allegations of negligent surgery resulting in severe and permanent injuries. Both cases were either discontinued or dismissed, potentially indicating settlements. The AAF argues that these cases, along with the previous ones, highlight a pattern of troubling allegations against Bertagnolli and question her competence as a doctor.