The judge presiding over the second E. Jean Carroll defamation trial against former President Donald Trump is screening any potential juror for a hint of right-leaning political beliefs. Judge Lewis A. Kaplan pressed potential jurors if they believed the 2020 election was stolen, if they have affiliations with groups like the Proud Boys, and if they’ve ever posted on Truth Social or Rumble. Potential jurors who answered in the affirmative are likely to be removed from the jury pool.
Five potential jurors have already been excused — three admitted they could not be fair in delivering a verdict, and two others said their ability to be impartial was impaired by what they’ve already heard or read regarding the several ongoing prosecutions of former President Donald Trump.
Attorneys for Ms. Carroll are expected to move to strike jurors identified by Judge Kaplan as having right-leaning political beliefs. While striking potentially unfavorable jurors is standard for the jury selection process, the active involvement of the presiding judge is uncommon — but not unheard of.
The ongoing law-fare campaign by the Biden government against Trump makes the selection of a fair jury difficult — as the ongoing prosecutions continue to receive a high level of media attention. Before the start of the second defamation trial, Judge Kaplan ruled Trump cannot challenge Carroll’s rape claim against him.
Last year, a judge ruled the former President had defamed Ms. Carroll and awarded a $5 million civil judgment against Trump regarding an alleged encounter in a Bergdorf Goodman department store dressing room in the mid-1990s. This second trial will determine additional damages for defamation linked to a statement Trump made in 2019 while he was still president, denying he knew Carroll and asserting that she invented the rape allegation to promote her book.
Judge in E Jean Carroll trial screening out basically any potential juror who remotely leans right, politically. https://t.co/oNEyWGr351
— Raheem. (@RaheemKassam) January 16, 2024