E. Jean Carroll says she plans to use at least part of the $83.3 million in damages she was awarded by a New York City jury last week to buy premium dog food for her Great Pyrenees and pitbull. In an interview this past weekend, Carroll said she won’t waste a cent of the awarded damages, claiming: “We’re going to do something good with it.” When pressed further, she mused: “I’m going to be able to buy some premium dog food now.”
The damages awarded on Friday vastly overtake the previous $5 million she was granted by a jury in a separate trial against former President Trump last spring. Attorneys for Trump announced their intention to appeal the defamation judgment.
Former President Trump is expected to file post-trial motions, including a Motion for Remittitur, with Judge Lewis Kaplan asking that the $83.3 million judgment be reduced as it far exceeds what Carroll had claimed in damages. Post-trial, a judge can intervene and reduce damages if they determine the judgment far exceeds what is reasonable.
“Judge Lewis Kaplan has the authority to enter a conditional order of remittitur, compelling E. Jean Carroll to choose between a reduction of the verdict and a new trial if his court determines that the award is intrinsically excessive,” said Colleen Kerwick, a litigation attorney, in a recent interview.
Kerwick continued: “If that Motion for Remittitur is denied, it would still provide his attorneys with an opportunity to expand the Record on Appeal as nothing new can be introduced at the Appellate level — the Appellate Court’s task is to look over Judge Kaplan’s work and determine if he abused his discretion or erred as a matter of law in his rulings.”
She also added it is likely Trump’s attorneys will challenge the constitutionality of New York’s Adult Survivors Act, which altered the statute of limitations that allowed Carroll to file a civil case on her sexual assault allegation. Trump has already challenged the law at the district court level, with any appeals likely to make their way to the Supreme Court eventually.