The five men convicted but later exonerated in the Central Park Five case are filing a defamation lawsuit against former President Donald J. Trump, stemming from remarks the Republican nominee made during the recent 2024 presidential debate. During the debate, Trump said of Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana, Kevin Richardson, Antron Brown, and Korey Wise, “They admitted, they said, they pled guilty.”
Lodged in a federal court in Pennsylvania, the lawsuit claims Trump’s remarks are defamatory towards the five men. The plaintiffs allege that Trump’s statement was untrue as the five then-teenagers never entered guilty pleas—although they did offer confessions related to the rape and near-killing of Trisha Meili, who had been jogging through Central Park in New York City on April 19, 1989. They were convicted of a range of charges, although all but Richards were cleared of attempted murder. Wise was also cleared of rape but convicted of other charges, including assault and sexual abuse.
While Trump appeared to suggest Meili was “badly hurt” and “ultimately killed,” she is still alive—expressing her unhappiness with the five receiving an eight-figure settlement in 2019.
CONVICTIONS OVERTURNED.
In 2002, the five men saw their convictions overturned after a sixth individual confessed to the rape. Matias Reyes’s confession was later confirmed by DNA evidence. New York City later settled a civil suit with the five men for $41 million in 2014.
The issue resurfaced during the debate when Kamala Harris referenced Trump’s 1989 full-page newspaper ads advocating for the death penalty for the men. Steven Cheung, a Trump campaign spokesman, dismissed the lawsuit as “frivolous” and politically motivated—Yusef Salaam is now a member of the New York City Council for the Democrats.
ATTACK DETAILS STILL MURKY.
Outside the attack on Meili, the then-teenagers had been part of a larger group of kids, estimated at 32 in total, who had set upon Central Park on the evening of April 19 and attacked numerous joggers. In an untaped confession, Salaam allegedly admitted to striking a female jogger with a lead pipe.
Despite Reyes’s confession to the crime, a subsequent report by the New York Police Department questioned whether the man was truthful in his insistence he acted alone. Doctors who treated Meili argue her injuries suggested multiple attackers.