On Wednesday, the British and French governments confirmed the end of the so-called “One In, One Out” migrant returns deal on boat migrants, casting doubt about the ability of Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s Labour Party to end the boat migrants crisis in the English Channel.
The “One In, One Out” deal was widely regarded as the British government’s flagship policy to address the Channel crisis. This is how it started, how it failed, and how Nigel Farage’s Reform Party could replace it:
Origins of the “One In, One Out” Deal.
The “One In, One Out” deal between Britain and France emerged from negotiations between former British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron in July 2025. The deal was supposedly intended to stop the influx of small boats carrying illegal migrants from France’s northern coast across the English Channel to Britain.
The deal stated that Britain could return migrants who had illegally crossed the English Channel to France, while France could send an equal number of migrants with family connections in Britain onward via an agreed legal route to Britain. Critics complained from the outset that this would likely keep the overall number of migrants arriving in Britain the same, but it came into force by August of the same year regardless.
🚨 NEW: The Government has confirmed the "one in, one out" migrant deal with France has now ended
The tally in August stood at 1,117 in, 1,087 out
— Politics UK (@PolitlcsUK) September 30, 2026
The Failure of the Deal.
Following a year of operation, the number of migrants affected by the deal remained small compared to the total number illegally crossing the Channel. August 2026 data from the British government revealed that 1,117 people were allowed into Britain under the deal, while only 1,087 were returned to France, resulting in a slight net increase in migrants.
Also in August, it was revealed that the agreement was costing £56,000 (~$74,000) per migrant. This followed an extensive lawfare campaign by pro-immigration charities and numerous reports of people been returned to France under the deal simply crossing the Channel again.
The End of the Deal.
On Wednesday, it was announced that the “One In, One Out” deal would not be renewed for another year, effectively ending the policy. This followed a previous three-month extension. The French Interior Ministry confirmed that Britain and France are discussing the terms of the deal’s termination, while the British Home Office has confirmed that it has stopped processing cases under it.
While both governments have mentioned future co-operation in dealing with the illegal migrant crisis, neither has proposed an exact alternative to the now-defunct deal, and reports of the French authorities turning a blind eye to Channel crossings are persistent.
Jordan Bardella: "Together, we must take back control of our borders." pic.twitter.com/vOMJnBb3ZS
— Reform UK (@reformparty_uk) September 4, 2026
A New Deal?
Earlier this month, Jordan Bardella, President of Marine Le Pen’s National Rally (RN) party in France and current favorite to become the country’s next Prime Minister, co-signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Reform Party leader Nigel Farage at Reform’s annual party conference in Birmingham, England.
The MOU states that France will prevent illegal migrants from crossing the English Channel, and that migrants deported by Britain back to France will ultimately be returned to their countries of origin. “Together, we must take back control of our borders,” Bardella declared in his speech to Reform members. While Macron and other establishment politicians have often seemed to allow the Channel crisis to spiral out of control on purpose, Bardella and Le Pen believe it is in France’s interest to stop the crossings, to deter migrants from entering France and setting up disorderly, often crime-ridden camps along the northern coast in the first place.
The month prior, Reform had announced “Operation Fortress,” a plan to deter the boats carrying illegal migrants with the Royal Navy. “We will ensure that not a single unauthorized vessel crossing the English Channel makes it to the shores of the United Kingdom,” declared Zia Yusuf, Reform’s Shadow Home Secretary, at the time.

