The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has formally reprimanded Judge Shelley Joseph over her involvement in a case where an illegal immigrant evaded ICE custody, citing her actions as creating an appearance of impropriety.
| PULSE POINTS |
❓ WHAT HAPPENED: The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court issued a public reprimand to Judge Shelley Joseph for her role in allowing illegal immigrant Jose Medina-Perez to evade Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody by exiting through a back door of the courthouse in 2018. The court cited her decision to instruct a clerk to turn off the courtroom’s audio recording system as creating an appearance of impropriety and violating judicial duties. 📺 DETAIL: Medina-Perez, a Dominican national, was in court for a fugitive-from-justice charge and two drug-related charges. Judge Joseph released him on personal recognizance after determining insufficient evidence tied him to the Pennsylvania warrant. During a sidebar conversation, she proposed detaining him overnight but ultimately allowed him to leave. His attorney had devised a plan to evade ICE custody. Joseph and a court officer were later federally indicted for obstruction of justice in 2019, though those charges were dropped in 2022 after she referred herself to the Commission on Judicial Conduct, which found her actions prejudicial to the administration of justice. 🎯 IMPACT: Judge Joseph, who was suspended from the bench for three years following her federal indictment, remains a judge but has been reassigned to administrative duties. The case has reignited debates over judicial accountability, particularly with respect to state courts’ interactions with federal immigration enforcement. 💬 KEY QUOTE: “Judge Joseph is thankful for everyone who stood by her and looks forward to rejoining her colleagues.” – Elizabeth Mulvey, Joseph’s attorney 📺 FLASHBACK: The 2018 incident drew national attention, as it occurred amid heightened tensions over immigration enforcement under the first Trump administration. |
Join Pulse+ to comment below, and receive exclusive e-mail analyses.