According to data from polling firm J.L. Partners, the Republicans’ midterm defeat was largely due to apathy from President Donald J. Trump’s base, rather than a surge in support for the Democrats. The firm surveyed 1,000 registered voters and cross-checked them against over 30,000 campaign interviews.
Trump Voters Generally Stayed Home.
The findings revealed that 35 percent of voters who backed President Trump in the 2024 Presidential election stayed home during the midterms. In contrast, only eight percent of Trump voters supported the Democrats.
“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House,” said James Johnson, Founding Director of J.L Partners, as quoted by The New York Post.
Which Trump Voters Stayed Home?
Trump voters without a college degree, over 65, and living in rural areas were the most likely to stay home.
Specifically, 46 percent of Trump voters without a college degree stayed home during the midterms. Meanwhile, 44 percent of Trump voters over 65 and 39 percent of rural Trump voters did not turn out.
According to the data, the absence of 2024 Trump voters accounted for a 10-point swing towards the Democrats.
Which Trump Voters Backed the Democrats?
Young, male, urban, and non-white voters who backed Trump in 2024 were more likely to switch during the midterms.
Trump voters between ages 18 and 29 were particularly likely to flip, with 16 percent defecting to the Democrats. In contrast, eight percent of Trump voters between 30 and 49 defected to the Democrats, along with four percent of Trump voters between 50 and 64 and six percent of Trump voters over 65.
Defectors were responsible for an additional five-point swing away from the Republicans during the elections.
Going Forward.
This polling underscores the importance of base turnout in winning elections, as opposed to moderating key policies.
“If Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again,” said Johnson.
According to recent polling from Navigator Research, a project of the Democrat-aligned Global Strategy Group, “Trump defectors” who supported the President in 2024 but voted Democrat in 2026 have a negative view of the far-left Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). The same polling revealed that 48 percent of “Trump defectors” were primarily concerned with the rising cost of living.
This suggests that far-left policies, such as abolishing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and defunding the police, are not popular with voters who switched to the Democrats.

