HM Treasury modelling of Andy Burnham’s reset for UK–EU Youth Experience Scheme has revealed: “The policy increases both GDP and the population (through higher net migration) by similar proportions, so the impact on GDP per capita is 0.0% at one decimal place.”
The finding, in effect, means hundreds of thousands of people flooding into Britain using the nation’s infrastructure while providing no net benefit economically.
The Treasury said this results from a compositional change: YES participants, being younger than the general population, are assumed to earn less than the UK average, on an earnings ratio of 0.81 taken from the same age cohort. “Therefore, the average falls very slightly. This does not affect the earnings of UK residents.” UK median earnings are given as £32,900; the age-weighted average used in the modelling is £26,500.
The scheme is for 18-to-31-year-olds, capped at 100,000 inbound and 100,000 outbound a year, for two years plus a possible third. Dependants are not yet permitted.
Aggregate GDP is estimated to rise by 0.1 to 0.2 per cent by five years after implementation, equivalent to between just £3 billion and £8 billion, in 2024 prices, when set against projected GDP in 2040.
On the same day, the Prime Minister sold the wider Brussels package as a boost of up to 0.5 per cent of GDP by 2040, about £17 billion a year: a GDP-level figure for the whole deal, not a per-person measure, and not a figure for the youth scheme on its own.
The National Pulse has already reported that the scheme would let Europeans compete for British jobs. The youth scheme’s own GDP gain is matched by population growth, so per person it adds nothing at one decimal place.
