A retired British police officer is facing up to six months in prison after he made a joke in a private WhatsApp group that had an offensive “implication,” dramatically expanding the boundaries of hate speech laws in the United Kingdom.
Michael Chadwell, who retired from the Metropolitan police in 2015, wrote a comment below a private WhatsApp post featuring multi-colored parrots alongside children of different ethnic backgrounds. The caption questioned: “Why do we cherish the variety of colour in every species except our own?”
Chadwell replied: “Because I’ve never had a bike stolen out of my front yard by a parrot.”
The presiding justice in the case, District Judge Tan Ikram, failed to find the humor in the comment, stating the joke implied that “black people steal.” He also refused to accept Chadwell’s claim that the comment was a harmless joke akin to Monty Python.
As a result, Ikram charged Chadwell with writing a “grossly offensive” message online, which, despite the standard being subjective and broad in scope, is an offense in the UK under the 2003 Communications Act.
“He thought it was funny, but it was grossly offensive, and he was aware of it at the time,” Judge Ikram declared.
Chadwell is due to be sentenced this month.
show less